Part I went over stress, tissues, the nervous system, and many of the factors that are involved with recovery.
Throughout a PT session there are many opportunities to influence the patient’s health; both for the immediate and long term effects. This post will go over the 4 factors of recovery that I often try to discuss with patients before they are discharged from Physical Therapy.
4 Factors of Recovery
Each of these 4 factors could be a book on its own, let alone a blog post. To save myself some of the mental stress of going over each of them in-depth, I’ll just briefly describe the factors and some methods for improvement.
Before you start educating patients, it’s important to follow the golden rule:
- Don’t prescribe anything you haven’t tried yourself
This goes not only for exercises, but the lifestyle changes as well. If you don’t sleep well, have never meditated, and eat bad food, then you shouldn’t try to influence other people.
Sleep is a difficult one. Going to bed at a descent hour is extremly difficult these days. Youtube, reddit, twitter, league pass, and Netflix (how can you just watch 1 episode of House of Cards?). But it’s one of the easiest ways to improve recovery.
Sleep gives us the lowest level of stress (internal & external) on the body. This low level of stress allows us to get out of the red and into the black. It lets us recover. Both mentally and physically.
The science behind sleep (and why we need it) is still not conclusive. But we do know that sleep plays a huge role in hormone regulation (melatonin, GH, TSH, testosterone, cortisol, etc.), augments immune system function, improves cardiovascular function, increases cognition, and improves neural function (stimulate oligodendricytes, myelin, neural development/repair). Plus, the supine position puts the lowest load on the body.
Sleep expert at NIH, Dr. Michael Twery, sums up these benefits of sleep nicely; “Sleep affects almost every tissue in our body.”
So even if we don’t know all the reasons behind why we sleep, we at least know that it’s good for you.
Most experts agree that you need at least 7 hours of sleep a night. Of course it varies from person to person, but if you’re getting less sleep than 7 you might have trouble recovering from the day’s cumulative stress (especially if you’ve put extra stress on it; i.e. workout, injury).
Today’s culture creates quite a problem.
We have these bodies that were developed from over 6 million years of evolution. This slow, progressive, evolution of our physical body has given us the genes we have today. Even though we’ve become a different species than our ancestors, we still share many of the same genes. Thus, we share a similar body type as our ancestors.
On the other hand, our cultural evolution has skyrocketed in the last 10,000-50,000 years, leaving our physical bodies way behind. And this cultural evolution continues to progress at an exponential rate. The Agricultural and Industrial Revolution were the first big events that changed the way humans live. Now we have the Information/Telecommunications Revolution. We are spending more time plugged in and less time present with our bodies. From this cultural evolutionary perspective, we don’t share much in common with our ancestors.
This creates a mismatch between the environment we live in and our physical bodies. In other words, our bodies are not made to live in today’s cultural environment.
The result of this, and the fact that we often treat the symptoms instead of the cause, is what Daniel Liberman refers to as dysevolution. A product of this dysevolution is the increasing amount of mental stress/disorder and physical dysfunction.
Luckily for us, there is a method to help prevent or decrease this mental burden – Meditation.
Meditation has been around for possibly 5,000 years. Needless to say, it has some empirical evidence.
I have taken UCLA’s on-line meditation course with mindfulness expert, Diana Winston. While this by no means makes me an authority on the subject, it has educated me on some of the science behind meditation and how to apply it.
The benefits of meditation are incredible and the profound effects cannot be overstated. Many people talk about the life changing effects of this practice. Even some of the most successful people in our society have credited meditation as a big part of their growth and accomplishments.
But even if empirical evidence doesn’t convince you, modern research has shown many positive effects.
Research Has Shown That Meditation Can
- Improve Physical Health (e.g. cardiovascular, immune system)
- Improve Mental Health (e.g. anxiety, depression)
- Improve Emotion Regulation
- Decrease Sympathetic Drive
- Improve Attention (e.g. conflict attention, improve flow)
- Improve Brain Function (e.g. neurodevelopment, gyrification)
- Decrease Pain
- Improve Well-Being
Sounds pretty good, right?
And did I mention that it’s free and easy? Well…it’s free and physically easy. Developing your meditation practice is a process and requires some motivation and mental effort. But don’t take that as a deterrent, it’s not exhausting or mentally fatiguing. In fact, most people feel energized after meditating. The most difficult part is getting started and developing the habit of meditating.
I think one of the best places to start is with Diana Winston’s 5 minute breathing meditation (YouTube).
This is a great place to start for 3 reasons:
1) Everyone can perform 5 minutes
2) It goes over the basics and gives you a standard guideline for future meditations
3) The diaphragm is the only voluntary muscle that can directly influence the autonomic nervous system. Breathing augments the parasympathetic response of meditation.
It’s important to note that I don’t immediately jump directly from discussing a painful shoulder to giving them a 5 minute meditation recommendation.
Before I prescribe meditation to a patient, I first educate them on the autonomic nervous system continuum (sympathetic vs. parasympathetic). Then I begin to explain some of the benefits of meditation and how it can aide in their recovery. If they are receptive, I simply write down my meditation recommendation (above), tell them to type it in on google, find a quiet place, and try the 5 minute meditation.
One benefit of our accelerated cultural evolution is that there are now plenty of meditation guides, timers, apps, and techno-bio-feedback devices that give people an easy way to stay on top of their meditation practice.
Bringing up diet is a lot like bringing up politics. Everyone has an opinion and no one knows what’s really going on.
Do we eat nothing but bacon? Is carbohydrate a bad word? Is there a chocolate diet?
However, more science and less propaganda has allowed for a recent paradigm shift in diet. We’re only scratching the surface and the answers will vary per person and per culture. But it has gotten a lot better than that terrible food pyramid we were taught to believe.
Trends will come and go, but I feel that there are 5 facts that would help most people. Of course there are a lot more to these “facts” than a simple sentence, but hopefully it’ll give some direction for nutrition choices.
5 Nutritional Facts
- Avoid Processed Foods
- Eat More Vegetables
- Avoid Simple Carbohydrates
- Fat is Not Bad for You*
- Stay Hydrated
I don’t think these 5 Facts will change as they seem to be backed up by basic physiology, logic, and evolutionary medicine. We may learn more about the specifics of each category, but the basic principle shouldn’t change. For example, it is now well known that fats are good for your health, but research is finding out which specific types of fats are healthy and which are detrimental (i.e. trans fats).
The benefits of exercise are enormous. Exercise improves the musculoskeletal system, controls weight, increases life span, reduces diabetes risk, improves mental health, reduces risk of some cancers, improves cardiovascular fitness, and improves sleep.
Exercise is also beneficial for recovery both:
• Immediately following a bout of stress
• For the long term ability to adapt to stress.
The immediate beneficial effects of exercise for recovery should be focused on the circulatory system. The goal is simply to get blood and fluids moving around. This should include some active dynamic stretching, mobility work, light stabilization, and/or light aerobic exercise.
The long term effects of exercise are much more complicated. This requires specific individualized programming that involves periodization and deloading. People should have a normal overall fitness and exercise routine to help stress the body for an individualized adaptation. Because in the long run, the body can only handle what the body is adapted for.
There are many great articles regarding the physical aspect of recovery. Check the references provided below for more detailed information.
It’s often not the over-training, as much as it is the under-recovery.
You can have the greatest training program and the best workout session from the best coach in the world. But unless you are able to recover from it, it won’t matter.
Bernard Hopkins, record holder for chronologically oldest boxing champion, sums this series it up nicely:
- “Lifestyle is the make or break of any athlete.”
I would even go one step further and say that lifestyle is the make or break of anyone’s health.
Now I’m not saying you should go out and give your patients a full nutritional prescription or start discussing their childhood to determine why their boss stresses them out. Instead, you should just be assessing the factors that influence their recovery and offering some general advice (if you are educated). Anything more than this would be beyond health promotion and fall out of the scope of your practice.
If someone is interested in a more in depth answer, you should refer out. The patient will benefit from a greater health “team” and the person you refer out to may even start referring in to you.
Signs & Symptoms of Overtraining
Chen, Jui-Lien, Ding-Peng Yeh, Jo-Ping Lee, et al. “Parasympathetic Nervous Activity Mirrors Recovery Status in Weightlifting Performance After Training.” Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research25.6 (2011): 1546-552.
Porges, Stephen W. The Polyvagal Theory: Neurophysiological Foundations of Emotions, Attachment, Communication, and Self-regulation. New York: W. W. Norton, 2011.
Walter, Chip. Last Ape Standing: The Seven-million Year Story of How and Why We Survived. New York: Walker &, 2013
Lieberman, Daniel. The Story of the Human Body: Evolution, Health, and Disease. New York: Pantheon, 2013. Print
Sugar is a Drug – Rejection of Low-Fat Dogma – Kris Gunnars Science – 11 Problems with the Modern Diet – Don’t Fear the Fats
Precision Nutrition – Boosting Recovery, All About Recovery
Hydration – Len Kravitz
BulletProof – Diet Infographics –
InfoGraphic – NIH – 11 Benefits of Sleep – Neural Repair – Sleep “Hacking” – Supplements (1, 2) – How Athletes Sleep – FatigueScience – Study on Performance – James Clear‘s Informative Sleep Guide – Farnam Street Shane Parrish’s Science Summary – NYTimes Schwartz – Sleep & Pain Correlation – Healing Power of Sleep – NeuroSleep InfoGraphic – 10 Reasons Why Sleep is Good – GMB – Sleep Deprivation = Cell Damage – Fix Circadian Rhythm – 2015 National Sleep Foundation Recommendations (Hours Per Night) – TNP on Sleep & Pain – Non-Obvious Sleep Solutions – Wear Sunglasses at Night (here & here) – Scientific American How to Be A Better Sleeper – Sleeps Role in Obesity & Psychological Disorders – 7 Steps to Better Sleep – Body in Mind’s Sleep, Pain, & Recovery – Eric Barker 5 Ways to Sleep Better – Sleep is good for learning and memory – The New Yorker “Why Can’t We Fall Asleep” – Relationship Between Sleep and Pain – Understanding Sleep – Sleep Builds Good Hearts – Optimizing Sleep for Memory – Sleep Restriction Therapy – Nick Littlehales 90 minute cycles and Ronaldo – National Institute of Health: Why Sleep is Important – Sleep removes neurotoxic waste from the brain – NYT Sleep. Clean. – NYT Sleep Problems and Type 2 Diabetes – Sleep & Recovery from YLMSportScience – The Sleep Judge on the Health Benefits of Sleep
Reimund, E. “The Free Radical Flux Theory of Sleep.” Medical Hypotheses 43.4 (1994): 231-33.
“Removal of excess free radicals during sleep is accomplished by decreased rate of formation of free radicals, and increased efficiency of endogenous antioxidant mechanisms. Thus, sleep functions essentially as an antioxidant for the brain.”
UCLA Mindfulness Awareness Research Center – Mindfulness Research Summary (Flock L, Flaxman G) – Gyrification – 7 Myths of Meditation –
UCLA – Mindful Awareness Practices (MAPs) I for Daily Living (On-Line). 2013.
CDC – Harvard – Exercise & the Brain –
Mike Robertson – 6 Tips for Recovery , Aging Athletes
Eric Cressey – 3 Tips for Aging Athlete
Chris Beardsley – Recovery
Kevin Neeld – Post-Game Sympathetic Dominance, Overtraining & Recovery
Dan John – Recovery Tips
Patrick Ward – Rest, Recover, Regenerate Part 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Seth Oberst – Recovery
Eric Bach (via Dean Somerset) – Recovery – Deloading
Blair, S. Physical inactivity: the biggest public health problem of the 21st century. BJSM.
The main reason I do this blog is to share knowledge and to help people become better clinicians/coaches. I want our profession to grow and for our patients to have better outcomes. Regardless of your specific title (PT, Chiro, Trainer, Coach, etc.), we all have the same goal of trying to empower people to fix their problems through movement. I hope the content of this website helps you in doing so.
If you enjoyed it and found it helpful, please share it with your peers. And if you are feeling generous, please make a donation to help me run this website. Any amount you can afford is greatly appreciated.
One response to “The Art of Recovery (Part 2 of 2)”
[…] Follow this link: The Art of Recovery (Part 2 of 2) – Aaron Swanson PT […]